Contextual Semantic Relevance Tracks fMRI BOLD Responses During Naturalistic Speech Comprehension
Kun Sun, Rong Wang
Abstract
Naturalistic language comprehension requires listeners to process both local probabilistic expectations and contextual semantic relations. This study tested whether contextual semantic relevance, measuring how strongly a target word relates to its recent semantic context, is associated with fMRI BOLD responses independently of word surprisal and lexical, timing, acoustic, and prosodic controls. We analyzed two public datasets: Alice (23 participants, one narrative) and Narratives (47 participants, 185 runs, four stories) using FIR/deconvolution and generalized additive mixed models. In Alice, semantic relevance was significant across all ROIs in FIR analyses, whereas surprisal was not. In GAMMs, both predictors showed broad significance. In Narratives, both predictors showed comparable spatial prevalence across ROIs. Semantic relevance showed robust BOLD associations across both datasets, with a particularly strong advantage over surprisal in the timing-sensitive Alice FIR analysis. The regionally heterogeneous direction of semantic relevance effects, with negative effects in posterior semantic regions and positive effects in frontal integration regions, suggests involvement of functionally distinct neural processes rather than a single uniform mechanism. These findings indicate that contextual semantic fit and local probabilistic expectation make partially distinct, dataset-dependent contributions to hemodynamic responses during naturalistic listening.
Topics
Classified with taxonomy v2 on Sat, 5 Sept 2026.